If you’re seriously considering a change in insurance providers, you’ve probably realized there’s no shortage of decisions to make—coverage limits, pricing, deductibles, carriers, exclusions, and risk tolerance, just to name a few.
But before any of that, there’s one critical question that should come first:
What should I look for in an insurance provider?
The reality is that your insurance agent and agency play a pivotal role in how well your business is protected—especially in today’s complex and rapidly changing insurance environment. Choosing the right partner isn’t just about price; it’s about expertise, advocacy, and long-term risk management.
Based on decades of experience working with thousands of clients across Michigan and the Great Lakes region, Top O’ Michigan Insurance Solutions has outlined a practical checklist to help you choose the right insurance provider for your business.
In 2025, insurance is no longer one-size-fits-all. Regulations, underwriting standards, and coverage forms vary widely by industry—and even within individual sectors.
Your insurance provider should:
Understand your specific industry and operational risks
Know common coverage gaps and exclusions
Stay current on regulatory changes and carrier appetite
Be able to explain why coverage is structured a certain way
For specialized or emerging industries—such as cannabis, manufacturing, construction, or professional services—this expertise is essential. The average insurance agent may have limited experience in niche industries, which can lead to costly oversights.
Not all insurance carriers are created equal—and not all are willing to insure every type of business.
A strong insurance partner should have:
Access to multiple carriers, not just one or two
Relationships with specialty and niche markets
The ability to compare coverage forms—not just premiums
Experience navigating hard or restricted markets
This is especially important in industries where insurance availability is limited or evolving. Access to the right markets often determines whether your coverage is comprehensive—or full of exclusions.
Insurance shouldn’t rely on a single point of contact. Your agency should operate as a team, supporting you throughout the life of your policy—not just at renewal.
Look for an agency that provides:
Dedicated service and account management
Claims advocacy and support
Policy change and certificate assistance
Employee benefits guidance (if applicable)
Loss control and safety resources
When issues arise—and they will—you want a team that knows your business and can respond quickly.
Insurance is only one piece of a broader risk management strategy. In 2025, the best agencies provide tools and resources that help reduce claims and improve compliance.
These may include:
Client portals with 24/7 policy access
Risk management and safety training
Employee handbooks and HR resources
OSHA logs and compliance tools
Cyber risk education and breach response planning
These tools don’t just make life easier—they can directly impact your insurance costs and loss history.
Price will always matter—but value matters more.
The right insurance provider helps you:
Identify real-world exposures
Structure coverage based on operations and growth plans
Avoid unnecessary coverage while protecting critical assets
Understand exclusions before a claim happens
Remember: the cheapest policy is rarely the best policy when it comes time to file a claim.
At Top O’ Michigan Insurance Solutions, we act as an expert buyer of insurance on your behalf—not a salesperson pushing a single carrier.
With seven locations across Michigan, 24/7 client access, and a team-based service model, we provide:
Competitive pricing and stable coverage solutions
Industry-specific expertise
Proactive risk management support
Long-term partnership and advocacy
We’re committed not only to protecting our clients, but also to giving back to the Michigan communities we serve through our WeCare initiative.
If you’re evaluating your current insurance provider—or considering a change—our team is happy to review your coverage, answer questions, and help you determine whether your current insurance truly fits your business in 2025.
???? Contact Top O’ Michigan Insurance Solutions today by emailing Service@TheSpireTeam.com to start the conversation.
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Back to Blog
Alpena
514 N Ripley Blvd
Alpena, MI 49707
Local: (989) 356-6133
Hillman
150 State St
Hillman, MI 49746
Local: (989) 742-4574
Traverse City
3183 Logan Valley Rd
Traverse City, MI 49684
Local: (231) 947-1164
Iron River
117 W Genesee St, Ste 1
Iron River, MI 49935
Local: (906) 265-5137
Petoskey
1170 Bay View Rd, Ste B
Petoskey, MI 49770
Local: (231) 347-4610
Gaylord
440 W Main St, Ste F
Gaylord, MI 49735-1401
Local: (989) 705-8664
Oscoda
PO Box 39
Oscoda, MI 48750-0039
Local: (989) 739-1461
Comments
There are currently no comments
New Comment