Business & Commercial

Farmers Need Protection From Environmental Damage Claims

A standard farm policy usually does not cover pollution or environmental contamination. Herbicide overspray onto a neighbor's crop is commonly picked up, but broader pollution exposures, a fuel or chemical spill, runoff into a stream, contaminated groundwater, and cleanup costs, typically fall under a pollution exclusion. Filling that gap generally takes a separate environmental or pollution liability policy, which is worth discussing with an agent before an incident rather than after.

What does a standard farm policy typically leave out?

Farm and ranch policies are built to cover the visible operation, the dwelling, the barns, machinery, livestock, and liability for ordinary farm activities. Pollution and environmental contamination generally sit outside that. Crop overspray of herbicides onto an adjoining field is often covered, which leads a lot of owners to assume all chemical exposures are, but that is where the assumption breaks. Product liability, and pollution liability in particular, are commonly excluded from the standard form (Farm Bureau Financial Services, farm insurance learning center). The gap tends to surface at the worst possible time, at claim, when cleanup costs are already mounting.

What pollution exposures should a northern Michigan farm think about?

Contamination on a farm rarely comes from carelessness. It comes from ordinary operations, equipment that fails, or weather. A flood or a hard storm across the fields around Hillman and Atlanta can move things that were safely stored an hour earlier. These are the common exposures worth walking through with an agent:

  • Groundwater and surface water contamination, including runoff into a creek or the Thunder Bay River watershed
  • Fuel, fertilizer, and chemical spills or releases
  • Improper storage of pesticides and herbicides
  • Release of noxious odors and dust affecting neighbors
  • Manure handling, transportation, and the operation of manure digesters
  • Damage to natural resources or nearby wetlands
  • Public nuisance claims and reduced value of neighboring property
  • Community illness traced to foodborne bacteria

Is environmental litigation against farms actually happening?

It is, and the scale can be startling. In a widely reported federal case in the Yakima Valley of Washington state, environmental groups sued a group of dairy operations over nitrate contamination of local drinking-water wells, arguing that the manure applied to fields should be treated as a regulated waste. The settlement required the dairies to supply clean drinking water to affected residents and to overhaul how they stored and monitored manure going forward. It happened on the other side of the country, but the underlying facts, manure, nitrates, wells, and neighbors, are not exotic to anyone farming in Michigan. Environmental rules at the state and federal level continue to tighten, and farms are, fairly or not, a frequent target of activist litigation.

How does this connect to agritourism and the rest of the farm?

The same policy gaps show up the moment a farm opens to the public. Hayrides, a u-pick field, a pumpkin patch, a wedding barn, or a farm stand add liability that a standard farm policy likely was not written to contemplate, and agritourism is one of the fastest-growing uninsured exposures for family farms. Michigan Farm Bureau has backed liability-protection policy for direct marketing and agritourism precisely because the exposure has grown faster than most farms' coverage (Michigan Farm Bureau, direct marketing and agritourism). If your operation is adding a public-facing revenue stream, that is the moment to have the coverage conversation, not the fall after. We touched on seasonal exposures in our mid-season farm check.

How do I close the gap?

Specialized environmental and pollution liability products are designed to respond to the exposures a standard farm policy leaves out, pollution-related property damage, site cleanup costs, bodily injury, and legal expenses, and they can be tailored to the size and type of your operation. What any given policy covers, and whether it fits your farm, is subject to underwriting, and coverage is not bound or altered until confirmed by an authorized representative. The value of sitting down with an agent is getting an honest read on where your current farm policy stops and whether a separate pollution policy is worth carrying for your operation. Gaps like these are common across business coverage generally, as we described in scary gaps in your business coverage.

Top O' Michigan has worked with farm families across northeast Michigan for 52 years, and we can walk your operation with you, from the fuel tank to the farm stand, to map where the real exposures sit. Start on our farm and country estate page or our pollution liability page, find the office nearest you on our Hillman insurance page, or call the team at 800-686-8664. We would rather have this conversation on a calm day than after a spill.

Back to Insurance 101

Questions about your coverage?

Talk to a local Top O Michigan agent well help you make sense of it.